Casey Key is one of the most secluded and prestigious locations in Florida. Due to its combination of wealth, limited building area (the island is only about 300 yards wide at most spots), and natural conservation that preserves its old world charms, the eight-mile island is a private paradise.Away from the crowds of the public islands, Casey Key Real Estate is just a few minutes away from all the major attractions of the city while existing in its own personal solitude.
Casey Key Real Estate Listings
44 Search Results Found. Showing Results 1 - 16.
DISTINGUISHED PLANTATION STYLE GULF TO BAY ESTATE on 1.6 acres with 17 foot elevation comp...
Listing Courtesy of: Michael Saunders & Company
Unspoiled Gulf to Bay Acreage on Casey Key! This has got to be the most unique waterfront...
Listing Courtesy of: Candy Swick & Company
"Oasis by the Sea" is a beachfront estate designed by renowned modern architect Guy Peters...
Listing Courtesy of: Michael Saunders & Company
Enter VIlla Toscana through a secluded circular motor court and you encounter a burnt-Sien...
Listing Courtesy of: Michael Saunders & Company
Casey Key modern and dramatic Gulf to Bay designed by Carl Abbott on wide sandy beach. Co...
Listing Courtesy of: Michael Saunders & Company
A Zen masterpiece on tranquil Casey Key. The essence of beach front living in simply beaut...
Listing Courtesy of: Michael Saunders & Company
This Casey Key Beachfront Residence is unique! Main residence is set back 100 ft. f...
Listing Courtesy of: Michael Saunders & Company
"Villa Mediterraneo, a gulf-to-bay estate on Casey Key, offers the buyer who is looking f...
Listing Courtesy of: Michael Saunders & Company
MEDITERRANEAN COURTYARD DESIGN HOME,WITH TWO LEVELS OF BALCONIES AND TERRACES. WALLED ROMA...
Listing Courtesy of: Richard J Simpson R E Broker
LUSHLY LANDSCAPED 3/4 ACRE LOT DIRCTLY ON 150' OF SANDY BEACH! THIS HOME IS SITUATED ON ON...
Listing Courtesy of: Michael Saunders & Company
The perfect Gulf to Bay getaway. Enjoy fantastic Gulf and Bay views from almost every room...
Listing Courtesy of: Signature Sothebys Internat'l
ENTER THE GROUNDS OF CASA AMALFI AND FIND PERFECTION FOR BOTH CASUAL LIVING & ELEGANT ENTE...
Listing Courtesy of: Michael Saunders & Company
Wonderful Location Mid Key Gulf to Bay Property. Cabana on Wide Sandy Beach and Boat Dock ...
Listing Courtesy of: Re/max Alliance Group
Fabulous opportunity to own on the Gulf or Mexico for under $3 million. This is not a tear...
Listing Courtesy of: Michael Saunders & Company
CASA MIA IS A GULF-TO-BAY DREAM COME TRUE ON CASEY KEY, WITH WALLS OF GLASS TO BRING THE P...
Listing Courtesy of: Michael Saunders & Company
Enter the coconut-lined paver driveway to a very special place. Charming bayfront residen...
Listing Courtesy of: Michael Saunders & Company
The land use of the isle is restricted to single-family residences, with many large estates spread the full width of the shore. Most estate properties on the island have private beach access to the Gulf of Mexico, as well as boat docking on the Sarasota bay front. The north end of island has resident's gate that is guarded full-time. The island is perched at an elevation that ranges between 400 and 450 feet above sea level, higher than most other barrier islands and greatly beneficial for residences on such a thin island. The natural environment and wildlife of the island are fiercely safeguarded by protective legislation, providing the residences with an undisturbed natural habitat, home to a plethora of native species of wildlife and vegetation. The south end of the key, Nokomis Beach, is the oldest public beach in Sarasota County, which has both beach and bay front, and is known to be the best place in the area for surfing, as well as observing dolphins and manatees.
Casey Key Real Estate ranges from a small 1 bedroom condo from the $240's up to beachfront estates of $20,000,000. The islands old Florida charm is one of Sarasota Florida's "Best Kept Secrets" private beachfront paradises. Some of the area’s most prominent citizens such as Stephen King live here.
Casey Key Real Estate
Casey Key real estate offers the most secluded, prestigious and wealthiest stretches of sand. Here you will find “Old Florida” in all its European-American splendor. You won’t find high-rise condominiums, beach apartments for rent, long retail strips, commercial hotels or generic chain restaurants anywhere on the island. In fact, aside from Nokomis Beach , there is very little public sand space on this 100-yard-wide paradise either. It’s no wonder that celebrities like Stephen King would choose to purchase property in this bridge-access key.
Casey Key real estate has a diverse mix of properties. Casey Key Road offers gated, gulf-front properties with boating access along Blackburn Bay . The Northern end of Casey Key backs up to Drymans Bay and offers a number of private beach access homes, which overlook the water but are situated a little further back. These homes come in quaint, low-maintenance cottages, cabanas and bungalows. Yet, along the Southern point of Casey Key, you’ll find sprawling waterfront estates and multi-million-dollar palatial mansions. Since there is such a limited area to build and contains less than 500 residents, the island is not overcrowded and remains a serene haven for retirees, vacationers and wealthy entrepreneurs. In 2005, Casey Key real estate owners saw their home values appreciate 50%, making it an ideal investment. Unique to Casey Key is an unusually high elevation that insulates the homes from any inclement weather.
It’s easy to see why Casey Key real estate was called “Treasure Island ” during the land boom of the 1920s. The glorious beaches allow for swimming, fishing, shelling, boating, picnicking, strolling, sun bathing, parasailing, kayaking, jet skiing and relaxing. Exotic birds line the shores and you can often spot a dolphin or manatee playing in the surf. Dense landscaping mixed with towering oaks and banyans add to the natural atmosphere, far removed from concrete playgrounds and city life. Most of the amusement here is in nature, although the island is a stone’s throw from Nokomis, Sarasota and Venice , where you’ll find all the big-city amenities, top-notch schools and hospitals, golf courses and tennis courts, museums and theaters. Airports, shopping centers, amusement park and other entertainment options are a short drive from your secluded paradise.
Life for Casey Key real estate owners is a departure from the chaos of life off the island. The average temperature hovers between 70 and 80 degrees and the beautiful sunsets visible from your back porch are just surreal. Affluent residents are drawn here by the pleasant weather and relaxing, rewarding way of life that’s hard to find elsewhere. Many people feel as though they own a tropical island all to themselves.
Casey Key real estate has a diverse mix of properties. Casey Key Road offers gated, gulf-front properties with boating access along Blackburn Bay . The Northern end of Casey Key backs up to Drymans Bay and offers a number of private beach access homes, which overlook the water but are situated a little further back. These homes come in quaint, low-maintenance cottages, cabanas and bungalows. Yet, along the Southern point of Casey Key, you’ll find sprawling waterfront estates and multi-million-dollar palatial mansions. Since there is such a limited area to build and contains less than 500 residents, the island is not overcrowded and remains a serene haven for retirees, vacationers and wealthy entrepreneurs. In 2005, Casey Key real estate owners saw their home values appreciate 50%, making it an ideal investment. Unique to Casey Key is an unusually high elevation that insulates the homes from any inclement weather.
It’s easy to see why Casey Key real estate was called “Treasure Island ” during the land boom of the 1920s. The glorious beaches allow for swimming, fishing, shelling, boating, picnicking, strolling, sun bathing, parasailing, kayaking, jet skiing and relaxing. Exotic birds line the shores and you can often spot a dolphin or manatee playing in the surf. Dense landscaping mixed with towering oaks and banyans add to the natural atmosphere, far removed from concrete playgrounds and city life. Most of the amusement here is in nature, although the island is a stone’s throw from Nokomis, Sarasota and Venice , where you’ll find all the big-city amenities, top-notch schools and hospitals, golf courses and tennis courts, museums and theaters. Airports, shopping centers, amusement park and other entertainment options are a short drive from your secluded paradise.
Life for Casey Key real estate owners is a departure from the chaos of life off the island. The average temperature hovers between 70 and 80 degrees and the beautiful sunsets visible from your back porch are just surreal. Affluent residents are drawn here by the pleasant weather and relaxing, rewarding way of life that’s hard to find elsewhere. Many people feel as though they own a tropical island all to themselves.
It’s easy to see why Casey Key real estate was called “Treasure Island ” during the land boom of the 1920s. The glorious beaches allow for swimming, fishing, shelling, boating, picnicking, strolling, sun bathing, parasailing, kayaking, jet skiing and relaxing. Exotic birds line the shores and you can often spot a dolphin or manatee playing in the surf. Dense landscaping mixed with towering oaks and banyans add to the natural atmosphere, far removed from concrete playgrounds and city life. Most of the amusement here is in nature, although the island is a stone’s throw from Nokomis, Sarasota and Venice , where you’ll find all the big-city amenities, top-notch schools and hospitals, golf courses and tennis courts, museums and theaters. Airports, shopping centers, amusement park and other entertainment options are a short drive from your secluded paradise.
Life for Casey Key real estate owners is a departure from the chaos of life off the island. The average temperature hovers between 70 and 80 degrees and the beautiful sunsets visible from your back porch are just surreal. Affluent residents are drawn here by the pleasant weather and relaxing, rewarding way of life that’s hard to find elsewhere. Many people feel as though they own a tropical island all to themselves.
My Account
Log in, to view your saved searches and add to your favorite listings.
... So You Can:
- View detailed property information
- Print detailed property flyers
- Save your searches & favorite homes
- Inquire about a private showing
- Map individual property locations
- Share your favorite homes with friends
Waterfront Best Opportunities
- Waterfront Foreclosures
- Waterfront Short Sales
- Listed Today
- Motivated Sellers
- Waterfront Bargains
- Featured Listings
Search The Sarasota MLS
- Search By Waterfront
- Search By Keyword
- Search By Map
- Search MLS Number
- Search By City
- Search By School
- Search By Zip
- Search By Subdivision
Sarasota Keys and Islands
- Siesta Key
- Casey Key
- Longboat Key
- St Armands/Lido Key
- Manasota Key
- Bird Key
- Venice Island
- Anna Maria Island
- Boca Grande
- Mainland Waterfront
Waterfront Communities
- West of Trail
- Siesta Isles
- Sanderling Club
- Orchid Beach Club
- Ritz Carlton Downtown
- Ritz Carlton Lido Beach
- Summer Cove
- Palm Bay Club
- Longboat Key Club
- 1350 Main St
- One Hundred Central
- The Plaza at Five Points
- Sarabande
- Sarasota Surf & Raquet
- Southbay Yacht
- Sorrento Shores
412 S. Tamiami Trail,